Two wonderful museums recently announced plans to sell major works of art. In one case, some 40 paintings, American masterpieces among them, will be sold at auction. In another, more than 400 photographs will also be sold. The former case has prompted a nationwide outcry, the latter…effectively nothing. The differences and similarities between the two underscore the aspirational rules that govern what is known as “deaccessioning,” but also remind us that principles and the goals they are meant to reach are not always the same thing.
Topics: Berkshire Museum, Deaccessioning, MoMA, Pittsfield, General Electric, Housatonic, Lake Onota, Museum of Fine Arts Boston, Metropolitan Museum of Art, Norman Rockwell, Frederic Church, Albert Bierstadt, Alexander Calder, Zenas Crane, Williamstown, Lenox, North Adams, Mass MoCA, Lee Rosenbaum, Felix Salmon, Association of Art Museum Directors, American Alliance of Museums, AAM, AAMD, Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts, Delaware Museum of Art, Waconah Park
Topics: authentication, Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Alexander Calder, Keith Haring Foundation, Agnes Martin, catalogue raisonné, connoisseurship, New York City Bar Association, Mayor Gallery Ltd, Peter Doig
A pair of recent disputes over sculpture, fair use and moral rights highlights the ongoing concern that Prince v. Cariou has made things worse, not better. The first concerns the estate of sculptor David Smith, and sculptor Lauren Clay. As Art in America put it, “Clay's works replicate the shapes of Smith's large metal ‘Cubi’ sculptures at tabletop scale in materials such as paper, and with faux wood grain or marble finishes.’ The Smith estate, through its reprsentatives at VAGA, took issue with this as a violation of Smith’s copyright. During the discussion, VAGA apparently proposed an agreement in which Clay would agree either not to sell the works, or only to display them with a disclaimer that the works were not authorized.
Topics: VAGA, Donn Zaretsky, Yellow Submarine, Art in America, La Grande Vitesse, Prince v. Cariou, the Donald Smith Estate, Visual Artists Rights Act, Sergio Muñoz Sarmiento, VARA, Alexander Calder, Copyright, intellectual property, Fair Use, Lauren Clay, David Dodde